Kconfig
Zephyr RTOS building blocks :: Device Tree Source :: Kconfig :: cmake :: `west` manifest files
Keywords: multi-core dual-core SECOND_CORE_BOOT_ADDRESS_MCUX code-cpu1-partition
This Neela Nurseries page dedicated to notes on Kconfig configuration system, and language. Some useful Kconfig links are given in the first section of this wiki page. One thing of note, it looks like as of 2022 Q4 Kconfig is parsed, processed, and or otherwise supported in part by Python based scripts. While Python does not have a fixed variable name length limit, Kconfig in contrast support variable names only up to forty or so characters in length. Longer variable name choices in Kconfig files appear to have an effect of silent variable assignment failures.
Another less than obvious failure during a project compilation which involves Kconfig processing as a step, is that a second assignment to an already defined and assigned variable, e.g. using Kconfig's ':=' operator or syntax, results in a syntax error message. Contributor to this article Ted surmises that this is due to the variable already being expanded to its first assigned value when the second mistakenly expressed assignment is reached during the project build process.
In both these cases, however, the error messages from Kconfig processor are not obvious pointers to the problems at hand!
Contents
^ Starting Points and Good References
A good starting point is at Zephyr's latest documentation as of Zephyr 3.2.99. The following link is itself one of five Zephyr docs pages linked from a parent doc page:
Need to revisit this link to identify its specific topics . . .
Some more useful articles on Kconfig, hosted at Nordic Semi:
Above Kconfig articles linked to from https://developer.nordicsemi.com/nRF_Connect_SDK/doc/latest/zephyr/guides/build/index.html#kconfig.
^ To Invoke Menuconfig From Other Than Project Root
If `zephyr_app` is a project, possibly a "remote" project in a multicore project, and is located two directories below the root of the larger mulitcore, effectively multi-app project, then the following invocation will succeed in opening Kconfig's interactive `menuconfig` interface:
$ west build -b zephyr_app -t menuconfig -- -DBOARD_ROOT=../..
^ Kconfig Interactive Use To Enable IIS2DH
Following messages do not show the interactive, ncurses based Kconfig configuration program. But these do show where Kconfig stores a modified configuration file in a given project:
ted@localhost:~/projects/zephyr-based/z4-sandbox-kionix-work/kionix-driver-demo$ west build -t menuconfig -- west build: running target menuconfig [0/1] cd /home/ted/projects/zephyr-based/z4-sandbox-kionix-work/kionix-dri...ed/projects/zephyr-based/z4-sandbox-kionix-work/kionix-driver-demo/Kconfig Loaded configuration '/home/ted/projects/zephyr-based/z4-sandbox-kionix-work/kionix-driver-demo/build/zephyr/.config' Configuration saved to '/home/ted/projects/zephyr-based/z4-sandbox-kionix-work/kionix-driver-demo/build/zephyr/.config' ted@localhost:~/projects/zephyr-based/z4-sandbox-kionix-work/kionix-driver-demo$
^ Kconfig formatting and variable names
Kconfig variable name length appears to have a finite length rule, which when broken causes a silent failure of Kconfig processing tools to assign a value to the given variable. The following Expressif documentation page goes into a bit of detail on this topic:
A summary excerpt from this Expressif page is:
Kconfig Formatting Rules
The following attributes of Kconfig files are standardized:
Within any menu, option names should have a consistent prefix. The prefix length is currently set to at least 3 characters.
The indentation style is 4 characters created by spaces. All sub-items belonging to a parent item are indented by one level deeper. For example, menu is indented by 0 characters, the config inside of the menu by 4 characters, the help of the config by 8 characters and the text of the help by 12 characters.
No trailing spaces are allowed at the end of the lines.
The maximum length of options is set to 40 characters.
The maximum length of lines is set to 120 characters.
Format checker
tools/check_kconfigs.py is provided for checking the Kconfig formatting rules. The checker checks all Kconfig and Kconfig.projbuild files in the ESP-IDF directory and generates a new file with suffix .new with some recommendations how to fix issues (if there are any). Please note that the checker cannot correct all rules and the responsibility of the developer is to check and make final corrections in order to pass the tests. For example, indentations will be corrected if there isn’t some misleading previous formatting but it cannot come up with a common prefix for options inside a menu.
Note: Expressif's Kconfig format checker looks like an interesting tool. NEED to investigate this script - 2022-12-23 Friday.
^ Kconfig NXP dual core setting
In Zephyr 3.2.0 representing a Zephyr RTOS Project with several years' maturity and development, there are yet just a few projects which support multi-core micro-controllers (MCUs). This most likely reflects that a large number of 32-bit MCUs in 2022 are yet single core. Zephyr multi-core sample applications have an interesting way, in the Zephyr source tree, of obtaining the second core's boot address from device tree source.
There are a few levels of indirection to get from the original declaration and assignment of a core's firmware boot address in device tree, into the project's source code. Zephyr's build system generates a certain amount of header files and C sourced code early in a project's build process. Namely these generated C sources cover a lot of the system or MCU initialization tasks.
One of Zephyr's multi-core samples is found in `zephyr/samples/drivers/ipm/ipm_mcux`. In case these "leading edge / main branch" link goes stale for some change in Zephyr Project directory structure, we here not that v3.2.0 Zephyr release has commit hash 4256cd41df6c60f1832fd2deb14edc30ac7debab.
Searching for this Kconfig symbol from Zephyr project root:
ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr$ grep -nr SECOND_CORE_BOOT_ADDRESS_MCUX ./*
./boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69/CMakeLists.txt:25: -offset ${CONFIG_SECOND_CORE_BOOT_ADDRESS_MCUX}
./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc54xxx/Kconfig.soc:54:config SECOND_CORE_BOOT_ADDRESS_MCUX
./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc54xxx/soc.c:134:#define CORE_M0_BOOT_ADDRESS ((void *)CONFIG_SECOND_CORE_BOOT_ADDRESS_MCUX)
./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc55xxx/Kconfig.soc:135:config SECOND_CORE_BOOT_ADDRESS_MCUX
ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr$
From file `zephyr/soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc55xxx/Kconfig.soc`:
118 code-cpu1-partition 119 config SECOND_CORE_MCUX 120 bool "LPC55xxx's second core" 121 depends on HAS_MCUX 122 help 123 Driver for second core startup 124 125 config SECOND_IMAGE_MCUX 126 depends on SECOND_CORE_MCUX 127 string "Binary image of second core's code" 128 help 129 This points to the image file for the the binary code that will be 130 used by the second core. 131 132 # Workaround for not being able to have commas in macro arguments 133 DT_CHOSEN_Z_CODE_CPU1_PARTITION := zephyr,code-cpu1-partition 134 135 config SECOND_CORE_BOOT_ADDRESS_MCUX 136 depends on SECOND_CORE_MCUX 137 hex "Address the second core will boot at" 138 default $(dt_chosen_reg_addr_hex,$(DT_CHOSEN_Z_CODE_CPU1_PARTITION)) 139 help 140 This is the address the second core will boot from. 141 142 endif # SOC_SERIES_LPC55XXX
We need to search further and understand how the Kconfig stanza at line 138 in excerpt just above works. This line appears to make use of what may be a Kconfig function, as discussed in this Zephyr 3.2.0 document on Custom Kconfig Preprocessor Functions.
ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr$ grep -nr DT_CHOSEN_Z_CODE_CPU1_PARTITION ./*
./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc55xxx/Kconfig.soc:133:DT_CHOSEN_Z_CODE_CPU1_PARTITION := zephyr,code-cpu1-partition
./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc55xxx/Kconfig.soc:138: default $(dt_chosen_reg_addr_hex,$(DT_CHOSEN_Z_CODE_CPU1_PARTITION))
Binary file ./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc55xxx/.Kconfig.soc.swp matches
ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr$ grep -nr zephyr,code-cpu1-partition ./*
./boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69/lpcxpresso55s69_cpu0.dts:39: zephyr,code-cpu1-partition = &slot1_partition;
./boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69/CMakeLists.txt:20: #offset is taken from zephyr,code-cpu1-partition
./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc55xxx/Kconfig.soc:133:DT_CHOSEN_Z_CODE_CPU1_PARTITION := zephyr,code-cpu1-partition
Binary file ./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc55xxx/.Kconfig.soc.swp matches
ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr$ cd ./boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69
ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr/boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69$ ls
board.cmake Kconfig.defconfig lpcxpresso55s69_cpu1_defconfig lpcxpresso55s69_ns_defconfig pinmux.c
CMakeLists.txt lpcxpresso55s69_cpu0_defconfig lpcxpresso55s69_cpu1.dts lpcxpresso55s69_ns.dts pre_dt_board.cmake
doc lpcxpresso55s69_cpu0.dts lpcxpresso55s69_cpu1.yaml lpcxpresso55s69_ns.yaml
Kconfig.board lpcxpresso55s69_cpu0.yaml lpcxpresso55s69.dtsi lpcxpresso55s69-pinctrl.dtsi
ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr/boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69$ grep -nr slot1_partition ./*
./lpcxpresso55s69_cpu0.dts:39: zephyr,code-cpu1-partition = &slot1_partition;
./lpcxpresso55s69_cpu1.dts:23: zephyr,code-partition = &slot1_partition;
./lpcxpresso55s69.dtsi:129: slot1_partition: partition@30000 {
./lpcxpresso55s69_ns.dts:31: zephyr,code-partition = &slot1_partition;
ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr/boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69$
^ A Simpler Search
A search for setting and meaning of `zephyr,sram-cpu1-partition`:
The token `zephyr,code-cpu1-partition` seems important, as it is the value assigned to DT_CHOSEN_Z_CODE_CPU1_PARTITION in ./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc55xxx/Kconfig.soc:133. A search for part of this token gives the following `grep` search results labeled here (1). From these results we see most lines are build artifacts from compiling a couple of samples in the local Zephyr source tree. But the very first result looks like a device tree source line, which declares a device tree alias:
Grep search results 1
ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr$ grep -nr code-cpu1-partition ./* ./boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69/lpcxpresso55s69_cpu0.dts:39: zephyr,code-cpu1-partition = &slot1_partition; ./boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69/CMakeLists.txt:20: #offset is taken from zephyr,code-cpu1-partition ./samples/drivers/ipm/ipm_mcux/build/zephyr/zephyr.dts:13: zephyr,code-cpu1-partition = &slot1_partition; Binary file ./samples/drivers/ipm/ipm_mcux/build/zephyr/edt.pickle matches ./samples/drivers/ipm/ipm_mcux/build/zephyr/dts.cmake:7:set_target_properties(devicetree_target PROPERTIES "DT_CHOSEN|zephyr,code-cpu1-partition" "/soc/peripheral@50000000/flash-controller@34000/flash@0/partitions/partition@30000") ./samples/drivers/ipm/ipm_mcux/build/zephyr/zephyr.dts.pre:853: zephyr,code-cpu1-partition = &slot1_partition; ./samples/drivers/ipm/build/zephyr/zephyr.dts:13: zephyr,code-cpu1-partition = &slot1_partition; Binary file ./samples/drivers/ipm/build/zephyr/edt.pickle matches ./samples/drivers/ipm/build/zephyr/dts.cmake:7:set_target_properties(devicetree_target PROPERTIES "DT_CHOSEN|zephyr,code-cpu1-partition" "/soc/peripheral@50000000/flash-controller@34000/flash@0/partitions/partition@30000") ./samples/drivers/ipm/build/zephyr/zephyr.dts.pre:853: zephyr,code-cpu1-partition = &slot1_partition; ./soc/arm/nxp_lpc/lpc55xxx/Kconfig.soc:133:DT_CHOSEN_Z_CODE_CPU1_PARTITION := zephyr,code-cpu1-partition ted@localhost1:~/projects-sandbox/workspace-out-of-tree/zephyr$
File ./boards/arm/lpcxpresso55s69/lpcxpresso55s69_cpu0.dts:39 contains the following excerpted code:
17 cpus {
18 /delete-node/ cpu@1;
19 };
20
21 aliases{
22 sw0 = &user_button_1;
23 sw1 = &user_button_2;
24 sw2 = &user_button_3;
25 watchdog0 = &wwdt0;
26 /* For pwm test suites */
27 pwm-0 = &sc_timer;
28 pwm-led0 = &red_pwm_led;
29 red-pwm-led = &red_pwm_led;
30 sdhc0 = &sdhc0;
31 accel0 = &mma8652fc;
32 sdhc0 = &sdif;
33 };
34
35 chosen {
36 zephyr,sram = &sram0;
37 zephyr,flash = &flash0;
38 zephyr,code-partition = &slot0_partition;
39 zephyr,code-cpu1-partition = &slot1_partition;
40 zephyr,sram-cpu1-partition = &sram3;
41 zephyr,console = &flexcomm0;
42 zephyr,shell-uart = &flexcomm0;
43 zephyr,entropy = &rng;
44 };
Ahh and from this we see token `zephyr,sram-cpu1-partition` is not a device tree alias but rather a "Zephyr chosen". This looks like it may be similar to a device tree alias. Must confirm . . .
